I have made two attempts at offering a rational argument for monotheism. The first one failed, and Scalia challenged my second one. I did not respond to his challenge immediately because I knew it would require some additional thought. After putting it off for a while I have given it some additional thought, and concluded that my second attempt failed as well.
I’ve been working on some additional arguments, but haven’t thought them through entirely. If you were following the previous post, you might be interested in checking out the comments section again for my response to Scalia’s objection, and my new proposals. Hopefully you can weigh in on their strengths and weaknesses. If they seem to be sound, perhaps I’ll make them the subject of another post, “Omnipotence and Monotheism III”!