In the beginning of this year I wrote about an article in The Guardian that was sympathetic to pedophilia, and attempted to destigmatize it by using the same sort of talking points used to destigmatize homosexuality. Now, two articles have appeared in The Atlantic that are offering more of the same.
“I, Pedophile” is written by David Goldberg, a Canadian journalist who was convicted of for purchasing and viewing child pornography. While he agrees that child pornography is wrong, he questions whether jail time for such crimes is appropriate. As in The Guardian article, Goldberg describes pedophilia (or the Orwellian term employed by Goldberg, “the cross-generational lifestyle”) as a “sexual orientation”:
The main query that I am convinced will always be without an answer is why I am a pedophile. It is the equivalent of trying to determine why someone is heterosexual or gay. We don’t choose our sexual orientations. If we could, believe me, no one would choose mine.
It’s not just a journalist describing pedophilia as a sexual orientation. The second article, “What Can Be Done About Pedophilia?”, written by Alice Dreger, features a Q&A with Dr. James Cantor, Associate Professor of Psychiatry at the University of Toronto, and a specialist in pedophilia. He, too, describes pedophilia as a sexual orientation: “Thus, although pedophilia should never be confused with homosexuality, pedophilia can be meaningfully described as a sexual orientation.”
In and of itself, such a description is not shocking. Indeed, “sexual orientation” seems to be an appropriate description of what pedophilia is. And yet, “sexual orientation” is so closely associated with homosexuality and gay rights that it poses a problem. Homosexuality has been justified as just another sexual orientation, no different than heterosexuality. What happens, then, when we lump pedophilia in the mix as well? If sexual orientations are just facts that need to be accepted about human sexuality, and pedophilia is just another sexual orientation (just as inborn as heterosexuality and homosexuality, according to Dr. Cantor), then why oppose pedophilia as being abnormal?
While neither Goldberg, Cantor, nor Dreger are advocating for the social or moral acceptance of child molestation (adult-child sex), speaking of pedophilia as a sexual orientation (that is inborn and unchangeable) may serve to soften society’s moral opposition to such desires and behaviors, and that worries me. While we should seek to better understand pedophilia and promote compassion for those who struggle with these sexual desires, we must not normalize or moralize pedophilia.
HT: Wesley J. Smith
September 28, 2013 at 6:21 am
I lament our courts’ having elevated sexual preference to the level of civil right. It seems obvious that there are some preferences within human sexuality which should not be given expression. The court was shortsighted not to have understood that they were opening a door to a very dark side of human nature when they established the principle that the gamut these preferences should be equal before the law.
LikeLike
September 28, 2013 at 1:24 pm
Bernie Madoff’s financial orientation was towards “larceny-lia”, while hetero-honesty has heretofore been the mainstream. Are we then to condemn Bernie Madoff for his orientation towards larcenylia? STOP THE INDISCRIMINATE DISCRIMINATION!
LikeLike
September 29, 2013 at 6:13 pm
do you have an email where can I send you a question about something that I want to ask you about ?
LikeLike
October 2, 2013 at 9:49 am
Eventually this is where the homosexual agenda leads to. You can justify any behavior as “orientation” and there you go….
As Christians who believe in a moral standard given by God, even though I strongly disagree with the gay agenda, I don’t think its our job to change society so that as Christians we can live more comfortable. We live in a fallen world, our job is to show the light of Christ and the forgiveness that is available to all people whether straight or gay.
There is no point trying to rationalize and convince unbelievers of the pitfalls of these “orientations”, this is futile. In fact, homosexuality in the scriptures is on par with other forms of sexual immorality, greed and idolatry. So they are all sins in God’s eyes that we need deliverance from.
When a person comes to faith in Christ, it’s not about paying some homage to some religious dogma as some fairies may suggest. Rather it’s about transformation and that can only happen with a connection to Jesus Christ. Nobody is going to change because of religion, creed or philosophy, but people will and are being transformed by the Truth. Sexual deviant behavior, like homosexuality, is not beyond the transforming power of Jesus Christ.
Naz
LikeLike
November 4, 2013 at 1:42 pm
Aria, my email is jasondulle [at] yahoo [dot] com
LikeLike